Placebo for kids?
The New York Times today had a story about Jennifer Buettner, who is trying to make a placebo pill for kids, but maybe for all of us.
Is this a good idea?
We know that in many cases placebos do work, and we also know that they have very few side effects — a point for placebo pills!
On the other hand we also know that the key to placebo is to create expectations. Without people trusting the placebo to work, such pills will have no effect. So this means that the parents will have to lie to their kids (and maybe even believe in the placebo pills themselves).
The truth is that as a parent I am not sure how I feel about this approach. On one hand when my kids are sick I really want them to feel better and do so as quickly as possible (there were a few exceptions where my son was a bit sick and all he wanted was to put his head on me and sleep, which I enjoyed a lot). But I also don’t want to lie to them, and to teach them not to trust me — even if it is helping them at the moment.
So — if one of my kids were sick and I had such a pill, would I use it? I am not sure.
Hello,
I’m not sure you need to activelly lie to them. You could just say “Take that, you’ll feel better”, which is true.
As a kid, when I could not sleep, and I went to see my mother, she used to say me “I’ll give you a magic drink, and then you’ll sleep”, and she gave me water whith a bit of sugar (I, of course didn’t know it was sugar), and she mixed it well in front of me, and… it worked !
Did she lie to me, though ?
If placebos have a therapeutic effect, it is no lie to give it to your child and tell him/her it will help.
We can strive for purity of purpose, but few things are 100%. All we can hope for is a statistically significant effect.
Budweiser beer promise me that if I drink their product, my life will be better. Seldom have they delivered on their promise, but I still drink the swill.
There is really no need for this pill. The market is already full of placebos: homeopathic products. Since, for many, both the parents and the children are blissfully unaware that all they are doing is downing H2O, no lying is required. These cost more, of course… but that is because they are more effective ;o)
Thanks for the comments. I will try to get my kids on the blog next week
Dan
If child is sick enough to have a labeled disease, no need for placebo as a “proper” pill exists.
If child is not sick enough for a labelable disease, then use “magic” whether sugar-water and mumbo jumbo or expensive “medicine” in elaborate containers.
But what was that about holding the child while she slept? Is that human empathy of parent for child most effective?
Does it bother us to encourage the idea that being “sick” requires taking pills — as if that is the only possible solution, at least to the common ailments of childhood?
Or is it just a matter of choosing the most effectual suggestion from the pharmacopoeia to placebos to parenting?
–ml
Placebos were originally made to see the psychological effect a medicine had on a patient. The patients on the placebos did as well as those on the genuine medicine because they believed it would work or not. A kid is an amazing thing and up to a certain age they believe anything an adult tells them so giving them a placebo to ease a discomfort is good because it relieves their pain and also eases the adults stress or worry over their child’s illness. Perhaps the placebo is working on the adult as much as on the child so everyone is happy all round.
This reminds me of my daughter.
When she went to first grade, she came home crying for a whole week.
I gave her a necklace of an eagle and put it around her neck. I told her when she was at school and lonely and missing us, to look at the necklace because it represented all the Love that her family could give her. And she should think of that Love and of her Family and not cry.
This worked.
I saw nothing wrong in giving my child this placebo, I was just giving her mind something else to focus on.
We are a society of pill takers. I have always talked to my kids about how powerful their brain is and how they can think themselves better. Positive thoughts, common sense, old fashioned rest. Of course this is for “simply not feeling well” times. If there is a true medical reason for medicine then I am all for it. But children need to feel empowered and they are now both grown and still believe in this philosophy.We do not take anything unless its really necessary. For every pill we take there is a side effect including placebos.
The only parents who should have a moral problem with placebos are those parents who never perpetuated the Santa Claus Lie.
Dan
Funny you should write about this. I saw this piece on the Today Show and found it very disturbing. But, I was strangely distracted (attracted?) by this concept. I sided with the medical ethicists who were troubled by the lie inherent in this cure. I compared this approach to “booboo ice” and decided I was comfortable with “booboo ice”, but not a pill. The only way I can explain this boundary is that I think a child would mature to see booboo ice for what it is, and would not use booboo ice into adulthood. But a child who frequently uses a pill might be likely to use medicine to cure all ills in adulthood.
-Michelle
noelia video casero free youtube
tiffany patterson nude pics
antique double barrel shotguns
corbin bleu shirtless photos
miley stwart naked
super head nude pics myblog
flavor of love pumpkin nude pics
honey baked ham co prices
carrie inaba nude
lastchoas english com
premade myspace layouts german shepherds
angel meluka domain angelakalolaluv cooly3series7 info
virtual villagers walk through
craigslist for the inland empire com
dey know remix song lyrics
delta sigma theta sorority raleigh chapter
converting pounds to newtons
bluemarlin bar costa rica
stacked bob hairstyles layers
22 silencers handgun